Liver Cancer or else known as Hepatic Cancer is a serious and life-threatening medical condition that affects thousands of people worldwide. There are two types of liver cancer: Primary and Secondary. Primary cancer grows in your liver or inside the bile ducts in the liver whereas the Secondary cancer spreads to your liver from another part of the body.
Identifying the various aspects of liver cancer, including its signs and symptoms, diagnosis and treatment options, is crucial for early detection and effective management. This comprehensive guide will cover key topics such as the early signs of liver cancer, liver cancer symptoms in males and females, types of liver cancer, diagnosis, treatment options, and precautionary strategies.
Types of Liver Cancer
The health issue is categorized into two primary types: Primary Liver Cancer and Secondary Liver Cancer.
Primary Liver Cancer
Primary Liver Cancer originates in the liver and generally affects people who are dealing with risk factors such as Hepatitis or Cirrhosis.
- Hepatocellular Carcinoma (HCC): This is the most common type, accounting for around 75% of all liver cancer cases. It instigates in the hepatocytes, the main liver cells.
- Intrahepatic Cholangiocarcinoma: Starts in the bile ducts within the liver and represents around 10% to 20% of all primary liver cancer cases.
- Angiosarcoma and Hemangiosarcoma: This type is very rare and starts in the blood vessels of the liver, representing about 1% of all primary liver cancer cases. Angiosarcoma may well affect other organs as well.
- Hepatoblastoma: A very rare type of liver cancer that is usually found in children under the age of 3 years.
Secondary Liver Cancer
Secondary Liver Cancer, also identified as Metastatic Liver Cancer, is a cancerous tumor that spreads to the liver from a cancer that started in another part of the body. This is more common than Primary Liver Cancer.
Cancerous cells may grow in any body part, such as the colon, lung, or breast, and then spread to the liver. The issue is renamed after the organ where it started, like Metastatic Colon Cancer. It describes the cancer that grew in the colon.
Early Signs of Liver Cancer
Early detection of liver cancer can significantly improve the treatment results. But then again, the signs in the early stage may often overlap the symptoms of other liver diseases. So, it would be wise for you to seek medical advice if you experience any of the following signs:
Unintentional Weight Loss
Sudden and significant weight loss without any effort or purpose to lose weight can be a warning sign of liver cancer. The disease can negatively affect the body’s metabolism and make it burn more calories than normal. If you notice you are losing weight rapidly without altering your diet or exercise habits, you must consult a healthcare provider to identify the underlying cause behind this unintentional loss in weight.
Loss of Appetite
Loss of Appetite can be characterized by losing interest in eating or a lack of desire to consume food. This can be a symptom of liver problems, as liver-related disease or cancer may well impact the liver’s ability to harvest bile and other digestive enzymes, leading to nausea and a reduced appetite. If you unintentionally lose interest in eating and start losing significant weight, you must seek medical attention to recognize the cause and take suitable treatment.
Upper Abdominal Pain
Constant pain in the upper abdomen or right side is a common symptom of liver cancer. This pain can originate from the tumor pressing on neighboring organs or tissues, as well as swelling or inflammation of the liver. The pain can be slight or intense but can worsen with daily physical activities or after eating. If you experience constant pain in your upper abdomen or the right side, consult your healthcare provider for a thorough medical checkup.
Nausea and Vomiting
Frequent or persistent feelings of sickness and vomiting are some common symptoms of liver cancer. The health problem can have a negative effect on the liver’s ability to process toxins and waste products. This would lead to an accumulation of these substances in the body. As a result, you can have feelings of nausea and vomiting as the body tries to free itself from the toxins. You must seek medical attention to determine the cause and receive appropriate treatment.
Unusual Weakness and Fatigue
Another symptom is feeling tired and weak often. The disease affects the liver’s ability to produce energy and regulate metabolism, leading to an unusual sense of weakness and fatigue. In addition, liver cancer can cause anemia, which can contribute to feelings of tiredness and lack of energy. If you always feel tired and weak, you need to meet your doctor to identify the cause and receive proper treatment.
Signs and Symptoms
As the cancer grows, the signs and symptoms become more visible. Identifying these symptoms in the initial days can be decisive for timely diagnosis and treatment of the health issue. Also, it can save one’s life. Here are some common signs and symptoms of liver cancer:
-
Jaundice:
One of the main signs of liver dysfunction is jaundice, which causes yellowing of the skin and the whites of the eyes. This results from elevated levels of bilirubin, a yellow pigment that is a byproduct of the collapse of the red blood cells. When the liver can’t function properly, it cannot process bilirubin efficiently, leading to its accumulation in the body.
-
Abdominal Swelling:
An enlarged liver or fluid accumulation in the abdomen, known as ascites, can cause visible swelling in the abdominal area. This swelling can be painful and accompanied by discomfort or heaviness.
-
Dark Urine:
Darker urine can indicate liver issues. This color change is frequently due to the increased presence of bilirubin in the urine, which occurs when the liver cannot process it efficiently.
-
Pale Stools:
Stools lighter in color than usual indicate a blockage in the bile ducts or other issues with bile production and flow. Bile is crucial for assimilating fats; its absence in the digestive tract can lead to pale stools.
-
Itching:
Continuous itching all over the body can be a symptom of liver-related issues. This happens as bile salts accumulate in the skin due to reduced bile flow, causing irritation and itching.
-
Fever:
Individuals with liver cancer may experience a persistent low-grade fever. This can be the body’s immune response to cancer or secondary infections resulting from a weakened immune system.
-
Enlarged Liver Symptoms:
As the liver swells and grows, it can cause fullness or a palpable mass under the ribs on the right side of the body. This enlargement can be painful and may be connected with other symptoms like pain or inflammation.
Stage 4 Liver Cancer Symptoms
Stage 4 liver cancer is the most advanced and presents severe symptoms:
- Severe Abdominal Pain: Intense pain due to large tumors or liver enlargement.
- Significant Weight Loss: Rapid and noticeable weight loss.
- Loss of Appetite: Complete lack of interest in food.
- Jaundice: Yellowing of the skin and eyes.
- Edema: Swelling in legs and ankles due to fluid retention.
- Cognitive Issues: Confusion, difficulty thinking clearly, or memory problems.
Liver Cancer Diagnosis
Accurate and timely diagnosis of liver cancer is crucial for effective treatment and improved results. The procedure involves several diagnostic approaches that help detect the presence of cancer, determine its stage, and plan a proper course of treatment. Here are the primary diagnostic methods used in the diagnosis of liver cancer:
Blood Tests:
Liver Function Tests (LFTs): These tests measure the levels of enzymes and proteins in the blood that are produced or processed by the liver. Irregular levels can indicate liver damage or disease.
Alpha-Fetoprotein (AFP): AFP is a protein that is typically elevated in patients with liver cancer. Measuring the levels of AFP in the blood can help diagnose liver cancer and monitor treatment response.
Complete Blood Count (CBC): This test measures the levels of different blood cells, such as red blood cells, white blood cells, and platelets. Abnormal results can point to underlying conditions, including liver cancer.
Prothrombin Time (PT) and International Normalized Ratio (INR): These tests identify how long it takes for the blood to clot. Extended clotting times can designate liver damage.
Imaging Tests:
Ultrasound: This non-invasive imaging test uses sound waves to create images of the liver and can help identify tumors or abnormalities in its structure.
Computed Tomography (CT) Scan: A CT scan offers thorough cross-sectional images of the liver and helps detect tumors’ size, shape, and location.
Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI): MRI uses magnetic fields and radio waves to create thorough liver images. It is particularly useful for evaluating the level of cancer and distinguishing between benign and malignant liver lesions.
Positron Emission Tomography (PET) Scan: A PET scan involves injecting a small amount of radioactive glucose into the body. As Cancer cells consume more glucose than normal cells, they will appear to lighten up on the scan, helping to identify the existence and spread of liver cancer.
Biopsy:
A biopsy involves taking out a small sample of liver tissue, which is later examined by a pathologist under a microscope. This method can confirm the existence of the cancer cells and provide information about the type and grade of cancer. Biopsies can be executed using several techniques, including:
Fine-needle Aspiration (FNA): A thin needle is used to extract a small amount of tissue from the liver.
Core Needle Biopsy: A larger needle is used to eliminate a core of tissue.
Laparoscopic Biopsy: A slightly invasive surgery where a camera and instruments are inserted through small incisions to get a tissue sample.
Surgical Biopsy: A surgical biopsy may be essential in some cases when a larger tissue sample is removed during an operation.
Liver Function Tests:
These tests assess the liver’s capability to produce proteins and clear waste products from the blood. Common tests comprise of:
Albumin Test: Measures the albumin level, a protein the liver produces. Low levels may indicate liver damage.
Bilirubin Test: Measures the bilirubin level, a waste product processed by the liver. Raised levels can specify liver dysfunction or bile duct obstruction.
Prothrombin Time (PT) Test: Measures how long it takes for the blood to clot. Prolonged clotting times can indicate liver damage.
Tumor Markers:
Other tumor markers may be assessed besides AFP to help diagnose liver cancer and monitor treatment response. These markers include:
Des-gamma-carboxy prothrombin (DCP): Elevated levels can indicate liver cancer.
CA 19-9: Often elevated in cases of liver cancer, mainly cholangiocarcinoma (bile duct cancer).
Genetic Testing:
Genetic testing may be performed in some cases to detect mutations related to liver cancer. This can offer insights into the tumor’s behavior and possible response to targeted therapies.
Staging Tests:
Once liver cancer is diagnosed, additional tests are performed to identify the cancer stage, which indicates its spread. These tests may include:
Positron Emission Tomography (PET) Scan: Combines a CT scan with a radioactive tracer to detect cancer cells throughout the body.
Bone Scan: Identifies the spread of cancer to the bones.
Chest X-ray: Checks for the spread of cancer to the lungs.
Endoscopic Procedures:
In some particular cases, endoscopic procedures may be used to diagnose liver cancer. These measures involve inserting a flexible tube with a camera and instruments into the body to get images and tissue samples. Examples include:
Endoscopic Ultrasound (EUS): Combines endoscopy and ultrasound to get detailed images of the liver and neighboring structures. It can also be used to guide needle biopsies.
Endoscopic Retrograde Cholangiopancreatography (ERCP): Used to inspect the bile ducts and acquire tissue samples for biopsy.
Elastography:
This imaging method measures the stiffness of the liver tissue, which can help measure liver fibrosis and cirrhosis. It can be performed using ultrasound or MRI and provides valuable information about liver health.
Early detection and exact diagnosis are crucial for effective treatment planning and improving the prognosis for patients with liver cancer.
Liver Cancer Stages
Liver cancer staging is a critical process that helps determine the extent of the disease, its progression, and the most appropriate treatment options. Here is a detailed explanation of the stages of cancer:
Stage 1
At its initial stage, liver cancer is still restricted to the liver and has not spread to the blood vessels, lymph nodes, or other internal organs. Characteristics of Stage 1 liver cancer include:
- Single Tumor: There is only one tumor present in the liver.
- No Vascular Invasion: The tumor has not entered the nearby blood vessels.
- Localized: The liver contains the cancer that has not spread to lymph nodes or distant sites. This stage characteristically has the best prognosis, and the treatment options may consist of surgical resection, liver transplantation, or local therapies such as ablation.
Stage 2
In Stage 2 liver cancer, the disease is more advanced than Stage 1 but still comparatively localized. Characteristics include:
- Multiple Small Tumors: There may be more than one tumor in the liver, but they are usually small in size.
- Vascular Invasion: There will be at least one tumor that has spread to the neighboring blood vessels.
- No Lymph Node or Distant Spread: The cancer has not spread to lymph nodes or distant body parts. Treatment options for Stage 2 may comprise surgical resection, liver transplantation, ablation, or transarterial chemoembolization (TACE).
Stage 3
Stage 3 liver cancer is more progressive and involves larger size tumors or further spread within the liver. It is divided into three sub-stages:
- Stage 3A: There is more than one large tumor, or a single tumor larger than 5 cm that has spread to a major branch of blood vessels.
- Stage 3B: The cancer has reached the major blood vessels within the liver, such as the portal or hepatic vein.
- Stage 3C: The cancer has spread to neighboring organs (other than the gallbladder) or the outer covering of the liver (the visceral peritoneum). At this stage, treatment choices may include a combination of surgery, localized therapies, systemic therapies, and involvement in clinical trials.
Stage 4
Stage 4 liver cancer is the most advanced stage and specifies that the cancer has spread beyond the liver to other parts of the body. It is divided into two sub-stages:
- Stage 4A: The cancer has spread to nearby lymph nodes but has not reached distant organs.
- Stage 4B: The cancer has spread to other body parts, such as the bones, lungs, or other organs. Treatment for Stage 4 liver cancer characteristically focuses on palliative care to relieve symptoms and improve quality of life. Choices may include systemic therapies such as targeted therapy, immunotherapy, chemotherapy, and radiation therapy.
Additional Considerations
- Child-Pugh Score: Besides the TNM (Tumor, Node, Metastasis) staging system, the Child-Pugh score is often used to measure the prognosis of liver cancer patients. It assesses liver function based on bilirubin and albumin levels, ascites, encephalopathy, and prothrombin time.
- Barcelona Clinic Liver Cancer (BCLC) Staging: The BCLC staging system incorporates tumor characteristics, liver function, performance status, and complete health to guide treatment choices. It classifies patients into very early, early, intermediate, advanced, and terminal stages, each with specific treatment recommendations.
- Okuda Staging System: Another staging system that assesses liver function, tumor size, and the existence of ascites to determine the stage of liver cancer.
Stage 4 Liver Cancer Treatment
Treatment for stage 4 liver cancer focuses on managing symptoms and improving quality of life:
- Systemic Chemotherapy: Drugs administered through the bloodstream to target cancer cells.
- Targeted Therapy: Drugs that specifically target cancer cell mechanisms.
- Immunotherapy: Boosting the body’s immune response against cancer.
- Palliative Care: Managing pain and other symptoms to improve quality of life.
Chemotherapy for Liver Cancer
Chemotherapy involves using drugs to kill cancer cells. It can be administered systemically or directly into the liver (TACE).
Targeted Therapy
Targeted drugs attack exact cancer cell proteins, blocking their growth and spread.
Immunotherapy
Immunotherapy helps the immune system identify and attack cancer cells.
Treatment Options and Alternatives
Treating Liver Cancer involves a multi-faceted approach designed according to the patient’s specific needs, the stage of the cancer, and general health. Here are the primary treatment options available for liver cancer:
1. Surgery
Surgery is often the ideal option for early-stage liver cancer and suggests the best chance for a cure.
- Partial Hepatectomy: This involves eliminating a portion of the liver where the tumor is located. It is an appropriate option for patients with a single tumor that has not reached the blood vessels.
- Liver Transplantation: One option is replacing the diseased liver with a healthy donor. However, it is ideal for patients with early-stage liver cancer and underlying liver disease like cirrhosis.
2. Ablation Techniques
Ablation measures are slightly invasive and destroy small tumors in the liver. They are particularly beneficial for patients who cannot undergo surgery.
- Radiofrequency Ablation (RFA): Uses high-energy radio waves to heat and destroy cancer cells.
- Microwave Ablation (MWA): Like RFA, microwaves generate heat and kill cancer cells.
- Cryoablation: Involves freezing the cancer cells to destroy them.
- Ethanol Injection: Injects concentrated alcohol straight into the tumor, causing cancer cells to die.
3. Transarterial Therapies
Transarterial therapies send treatment directly to the liver, targeting the tumor while sparing healthy tissue.
- Transarterial Chemoembolization (TACE): Combines chemotherapy and embolization, where chemotherapy drugs are injected into the liver’s blood supply, followed by tiny particles that block the artery, trapping the drugs in the tumor.
- Transarterial Radioembolization (TARE): Radioactive beads are injected into the liver’s blood vessels to carry radiation directly to the tumor.
4. Radiation Therapy
In Radiation therapy, high-energy rays target and kill cancer cells. It’s often used when surgery is not an option or in combination with other treatment options.
- External Beam Radiation Therapy (EBRT): Directs radiation at the tumor outside the body.
- Stereotactic Body Radiation Therapy (SBRT): It’s a precise form of radiation that delivers high doses to the tumor while minimizing damage to nearby tissues.
5. Chemotherapy
In chemotherapy, drugs are used to kill or slow the growth of cancer cells. While it’s not as effective for liver cancer in comparison to other treatments, it is used in advanced cases.
- Systemic Chemotherapy: Drugs are administered orally or intravenously, traveling through the body to target cancer cells.
- Localized Chemotherapy (TACE): As mentioned, this combines chemotherapy with embolization to concentrate the drug in the liver.
6. Targeted Therapy
Targeted therapy involves drugs that precisely target molecular changes in cancer cells.
- Sorafenib (Nexavar): Prevents the growth of tumor cell and angiogenesis.
- Lenvatinib (Lenvima): Blocks multiple pathways in tumor growth and spread.
- Regorafenib (Stivarga): Used for advanced liver cancer that has developed despite other treatments.
7. Immunotherapy
Immunotherapy helps the immune system identify and attack cancer cells.
- Checkpoint Inhibitors: Drugs like pembrolizumab (Keytruda) and nivolumab (Opdivo) block proteins that prevent immune cells from attacking cancer cells.
- Combination Therapies: Combining immunotherapy with other treatments like targeted therapy or chemotherapy can improve the efficiency.
8. Systemic Therapies
Systemic therapies comprise both chemotherapy and targeted therapies that treat cancer throughout the body.
9. Palliative Care
Palliative care focuses on relieving symptoms and improving the quality of life for patients with advanced liver cancer.
- Pain Management: Using medication and other methods to manage pain.
- Nutritional Support: Ensuring appropriate nutrition to maintain strength and energy.
- Psychosocial Support: Providing emotional and psychological support to patients and their families.
10. Clinical Trials
Partaking in clinical trials offers patients access to new and experimental treatments that are not yet generally available.
11. Complementary and Alternative Medicine
Some patients explore complementary and alternative therapies to support conventional treatment. These may include:
- Acupuncture: This is for pain relief and managing side effects of the treatment.
- Herbal Supplements: This should be used vigilantly and under the supervision of a healthcare provider.
Cancer Prevention Measures
Preventive measures can significantly reduce the chances of liver cancer. People can reduce their chances of developing this serious condition by adopting healthy lifestyle choices and taking proactive steps. Here are crucial strategies for the prevention of liver cancer:
-
Vaccination
- Hepatitis B Vaccination: Hepatitis B is a major risk factor for liver cancer. Vaccination against Hepatitis B can significantly decrease the risk of infection and subsequent liver cancer. The vaccine is safe and effective, offering long-term protection.
-
Avoid Risky Behaviours
- Practice Safe Sex: Use condoms and engage in safe sexual practices to avert the transmission of hepatitis B and C viruses.
- Avoid Sharing Needles: Do not share needles or other drug equipment to prevent hepatitis C infection. Use sterile needles for tattoos, piercings, and medical procedures.
-
Limit Alcohol Consumption
- Moderate Alcohol Intake: Excessive alcohol consumption can lead to liver cirrhosis, a great risk factor for liver cancer. Limit alcohol intake to moderate levels, as suggested by health guidelines.
- Seek Help for Alcohol Addiction: If struggling with alcohol addiction, seek out professional help and assistance to decrease consumption and ease liver damage.
-
Healthy Diet
- Balanced Diet: Consume a diet rich in fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and lean proteins. Avoid processed foods and high-fat and high-sugar foods, which can contribute to obesity and liver disease.
- Antioxidant-Rich Foods: Include foods high in antioxidants, such as berries, nuts, and leafy greens, which can help protect liver cells from damage.
-
Maintain a Healthy Weight
- Weight Management: Obesity increases the risk of non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD), which can progress to liver cancer. Maintain a healthy weight through a balanced diet and regular physical activity.
- Monitor Body Mass Index (BMI): Monitor BMI and strive to stay within a healthy range. Seek guidance from healthcare providers for customized weight management plans.
-
Regular Exercise
- Physical Activity: Regular physical activity preserves overall health and decreases the risk of obesity and correlated liver conditions. Aim for at least 150 minutes of moderate-intensity exercise per week.
- Incorporate Strength Training: Include strength training exercises at least twice weekly to build muscle and recover metabolic health.
-
Avoid Toxins
- Minimize Chemical Exposure: Limit exposure to environmental toxins, such as pesticides, industrial chemicals, and pollutants, that can damage the liver.
- Use Protective Equipment: If working with hazardous substances, use defensive equipment and follow safety procedures to decrease the risk of toxin exposure.
-
Use Medication Safely
- Use Medications as Prescribed: Follow healthcare providers’ instructions when taking medications. Avoid overuse of over-the-counter drugs, particularly acetaminophen, which can cause liver damage in high doses.
- Avoid Herbal Supplements: Some herbal supplements can harm the liver. Consult healthcare providers before using supplements, chiefly those not regulated by health authorities.
-
Regular Medical Check-Ups
- Routine Screening: Get liver function tests and screenings regularly if you are at risk for liver disease or cancer. Detection of liver conditions at an initial stage can lead to timely intervention and better results.
- Monitor Chronic Conditions: Manage chronic medical conditions such as diabetes, hepatitis, and fatty liver disease with regular medical follow-ups and adherence to treatment plans.
-
Limit Consumption of Sugar
- Reduce Sugar Consumption: High sugar intake is associated with obesity and insulin resistance, both of which can raise the risk of liver disease. Limit sugary beverages and snacks.
- Choose Natural Sweeteners: Choose natural sweeteners like honey or stevia as an alternative to refined sugars.
-
Smoking is Injurious
- Quit Smoking: Smoking is injurious to your health, plus it is responsible for many types of Cancer, including Liver Cancer. Seek support to quit smoking. Also, you must avoid exposure to second-hand smoke.
-
Underlying Health Conditions
- Control Diabetes and Hypertension: Managing diabetes appropriately and high blood pressure can decrease the risk of liver damage and liver cancer. Follow treatment plans and lifestyle suggestions from healthcare providers.
-
Educate and Aware
- Raise Awareness: Educate yourself about the risk factors and prevention strategies and share it with others. Spread awareness for public health initiatives that encourage liver health and cancer prevention.
By integrating these precautionary measures into their daily life, individuals can greatly decrease their risk of developing liver cancer and promote liver health. Regular sessions with healthcare providers and staying informed about the latest prevention strategies are decisive for effective cancer prevention.
Signs of Liver Cancer in Females and Males
Even though liver cancer symptoms are usually similar in both genders, some variations may arise due to changes in hormonal profiles and how the disease affects the body. Understanding these differences can be vital for the early detection of the issue and proper treatment.
Symptoms in Females
- Abdominal Discomfort: Women suffering from liver cancer may well experience pain or discomfort in the upper abdomen area. This discomfort can be the outcome of the liver enlarging. Or the reason can be the presence of a tumor pressing on other organs. The pain can vary from a slight aching to sharp, severe pain that may be persistent or irregular.
- Menstrual Changes: Liver cancer can cause hormonal imbalances in women that might affect their menstrual cycle. These fluctuations include irregular periods, substantial or lighter bleeding than normal, or even missed periods. The liver plays a vital role in hormone metabolism, and its dysfunction can lead to important menstrual irregularities.
- Nausea and Vomiting: Women with liver cancer may experience more noticeable nausea and vomiting compared to men. This could be an outcome of hormonal fluctuations that are more common in females, particularly if they are premenopausal or experiencing menopause. Nausea and vomiting can also directly result from the liver’s incapability to detoxify the blood efficiently.
Symptoms in Males
- Gynecomastia: Men suffering from liver cancer may develop Gynecomastia, an increase in breast tissue. This condition occurs due to an imbalance in hormones caused by the liver’s impaired function. The liver is responsible for breaking down hormones like estrogen. When it fails to do so, estrogen levels may well increase, leading to breast tissue development in men.
- Testicular Atrophy: Liver dysfunction in men can lead to testicular atrophy, which is the shrinking of the testicles. This occurs because the liver plays a significant role in regulating hormones like testosterone. When the liver is not functioning appropriately, testosterone levels may drop, resulting in testicular shrinkage and other correlated symptoms.
- Loss of Libido: A reduced sexual drive is another symptom that men suffering from liver cancer may well experience. This loss of libido is often due to the hormonal changes and imbalances caused by liver dysfunction. Lower levels of testosterone can lead to reduced interest in sexual activity and may also be responsible to other symptoms like fatigue and depression.
Conclusion
Liver cancer is a serious condition that requires prompt diagnosis and treatment. Understanding the types, symptoms, diagnostic methods, and treatment options is crucial for managing the disease effectively. Preventive measures can significantly reduce the risk of developing liver cancer. If you experience any symptoms or are at risk, consult a healthcare provider for appropriate screening and intervention.
Listen to our Podcast on Liver Cancer, it’s Symptoms, Diagnosis, and Treatment:
Leave a Reply